Reports, albeit somewhat inaccurate, of the events in Candia (Iraklion) on 6th September 1898 were published in British newspapers the following day.[1] However, it took the bureaucracy of the British Army some time to catch up, particularly when it came to rewarding the troops concerned. It wasn’t until January the following year that the following despatch appeared in the London Gazette, the official journal of the British government.
War Office, January 24, 1899.[2]
THE following Despatch has been received, through the Governor and Commander-in-Chief, Malta, from. Major-General Sir H. C. Chermside, G.C.M.G., C.B., Commanding the British Troops in Crete:
Kandia,, December 16, 1898.
Sir, I have the honour to submit the following report as to the services of the Officers and others present when the British Troops in Kandia were attacked on 6th September, 1898. I was not present in Crete on that date, but in subsequently forwarding copies of the reports despatched by Colonel F. M. Reid, Highland Light Infantry, Officer Commanding Troops and Acting British Commissioner, I had no hesitation in endorsing his opinion as to the coolness, steadiness, and gallantry of all concerned, during a most difficult and dangerous crisis.
The Infantry called on to defend themselves, with the assistance of other detachments, against this sudden, general, and treacherous attack, all belonged to the 1st Battalion Highland Light Infantry, and behaved in a manner worthy of the traditions of this distinguished corps.
I recommend for favourable consideration the services of the following:
Highland Light Infantry.
Colonel F. M. Reid.
Major I. C. Conway-Gordon.
Captain A. G. Balfour.
Captain A. F. Lambton.
Captain E. R, Hill.
Captain and Adjutant J. W. A. Cowan.
Captain G. E. Begbie.
Second Lieutenant W. H. E. Segrave (wounded).
Quartermaster-Sergeant S. McNeill.
Colour Sergeant A.-Colville.
Colour-Sergeant J. B. Cameron.
Sergeant A. Gray (wounded).
Sergeant R. Murray.
Sergeant D. Christie.
Sergeant E. B. Underwood.
Corporal J. MacLean.
Corporal J. C. Harland.
Private D. Fraser (wounded).
Private W. Mason.
Private R. Jordan.
Private W. Guthrie (severely wounded).
Private Jos. Perkins (wounded).
Private W. Johnstone.
Royal Engineers,
Lieutenant M. R. Kennedy.
Sergeant G. Smith.
Royal Army Medical Corps.
Lieutenant L. Addams-Williams.
Lieutenant T. H. M. Clarke (wounded).
Private D. Philemon.
Private G. H. Lowden.
Private G. Leggatt.
Private G. Biddiscombe (wounded).
Army Service Corps.
Sergeant G. Gordon.
I have, &c.,
HERBERT CHERMSIDE,
Major-General.
War Office, March 7, 1899.[3]
The Queen has been graciously pleased to give orders for the following appointments to the Distinguished Service Order, and promotions in the Army, in recognition of the services of the undermentioned Officers during the outbreak in Kandia on the 6th September 1898. The promotions to bear date 8th March, 1899.
To be Companions of the Distinguished Service Order: —
Captain James William Alston Cowan, the Highland Light Infantry.
Lieutenant Macdougall Ralston Kennedy, Royal Engineers.
Lieutenant Thomas Henry Matthews Clarke, Royal Army Medical Corps.
Second Lieutenant William Henry-Erik Segrave, the Highland Light Infantry.
BREVET.
To be Lieutenant-Colonel: –
Major I. C. Conway-Gordon, the Highland Light Infantry.
To be Majors: –
Captain A.- G. Balfour, the Highland Light Infantry.
Captain G. E. Begbie, the Highland Light Infantry.
The Queen has further been pleased to approve the grant of the medal for Distinguished Conduct in the Field to the undermentioned: –
Royal Engineers.
Sergeant G. Smith.
The Highland Light Infantry.
Colour-Sergeant A. Colville.
Sergeant A. Gray.
Private W. Guthrie.
Army Service Corps.
Sergeant G. Gordon.
Royal Army Medical Corps.
Private G. Biddiscombe.
The Queen has also been graciously pleased to approve of the following promotions in the Army, in recognition of the services of the undermentioned Officers during the occupation of Crete, dated 8th March, 1899: –
BREVET.[4]
To be Colonel: –
Lieutenant-Colonel R. B. Mainwaring, the Royal Welsh Fusiliers.
To be Major: –
Captain Sir H. W. McMahon, Bart., D.S.O., the Royal Welsh Fusiliers.
ADDITIONAL NOTICE.
Lieutenant C. M. Dobell, the Royal Welsh Fusiliers, is noted for consideration for the
Brevet rank of Major, on promotion to the rank of Captain.
An analysis of the distribution of ‘mentions in despatches’, medals and promotions awarded after the events of 6th September illustrates the social hierarchy of the late Victorian Army. In 1898 1/Highland Light Infantry while based in Malta prior to and after, its deployment in Crete consisted of a strength of approximately 700 Officers and men,[5] the overwhelming number of whom would be enlisted men and N.C.O.s. In spite of this, one third of those mentioned in the despatch, 11 out of 32, were offices, and of those given some recognition for their bravery that day, seven were officers and six were other ranks. (The brevet promotions for the Royal Welsh Fusiliers were unconnected with the events of 6 September, the RWF returning to Crete, having served there from April 18907 to August 1898, as part of the reinforcements sent following the riots.) The inclusion of so many members of the Royal Army Medical Corps in the official Despatch reflects the fact that one of the significant locations for fighting on the 6th Sepember was around the British military hospital.
The Distinguished Conduct Medal, post-nominal letters DCM, was established in 1854 by Queen Victoria as a decoration for gallantry in the field by other ranks of the British Army. It is the oldest British award for gallantry and was a second level military decoration, ranking below the Victoria Cross, until its discontinuation in 1993. Coming with a gratuity paid on the recipients discharge from the army, all medals awarded bore the recipient’s number, rank, name and unit on the rim.
Distinguished Conduct Medal, Victorian version. (Later versions had the Monarch’s head on the reverse)
The Distinguished Conduct Medal awarded to Private William Guthrie, 1/ Highland Light Infantry, came up for sale in 2016.
The following biographical details of Guthrie were recorded at the time of sale:
William Guthrie was born in Ayr, and attested for the Highland Light Infantry at Hamilton, in January 1897. He was discharged, 17 October 1899, as a consequence of the gunshot wound that he received at Kandia. The latter was ‘received in action at Crete 6.9.98… defending the military hospital when wounded… Bullet appears to have entered one sternal end of 1st rib passed outwards under the clavicle (right-side) making its exit on the outer side of arm 2 inches below point of shoulder.’ (Medical Report refers)
Guthrie had only served for 2 years and 239 days with the Colours, with the D.C.M. being his only medallic entitlement.[6]
The Royal Navy also rewarded their personnel for their bravery that day. The highest British award for bravery in the armed services, the Victoria Cross, was given to Royal Naval Surgeon William Maillard.
[1] Cf The Morning Post, London, 7 September 1898, p.4.
[2] London Gazette 24 January 1899. p458
[3] London Gazette 7 March 1899. p.1586.
[4] A Brevet promotion was an honorary, and temporary, promotion for bravery or distinguished conduct. It did not confer any seniority within the recipient’s regiment.
[5] https://www.maltaramc.com/regmltgar/71st.html
[6] https://www.the-saleroom.com/en-gb/auction-catalogues/dixnoonanwebb/catalogue-id-dix-no10028/lot-e5ab651d-9d76-4f03-bfa8-a6c501127b41